Is PT Eatery Ready for P(rime) T(ime)?

**** You can find an updated post here

Back at the end of October, I noticed that Pho T Cali's sign had been covered over. Soon after "DerekR" mentioned that "PT Eatery" was replacing Pho T Cali and that the place was related to Phuong Trang. I went over that Saturday and yes indeed there was a PT Eatery sign up. A little over a week later Eater confirmed that this place was indeed going to sort of be Phuong Trang "light". Even though I think Phuong Trang is pretty much middle of the road Vietnamese.....or perhaps gateway Vietnamese? I decided to give the place a couple of tries.....

This restaurant seems to have kept most of the same décor from Pho T Cali throwing in a larger divider of faux (not pho) plants and such.

The young man who waited on me was really friendly and asked if I'd been here previously...…..I told him "no....how long have you been open?" He laughed and said "a week". As he handed me my menu; he asked me if he could recommend a couple of items on the menu......he was so very nice. He recommended the Beef Short Rib Pho...….shades of Pho Duyen Mai! So I went ahead and ordered it ($11.95).

While some of the basil was starting to brown; this was a decent sized portion of basil and sprouts....at least for these days. And of course; I expected no Ngo Gai and got none.

Soon enough my bowl arrived.

Let's first talk about what I liked about this bowl of pho....well, the broth was hot. It ended there. The soup was soooo salty, had so much MSG in it that all the other flavors were masked......there's not enough lime in world to fix this much MSG. I even added some water to see if it would help....of course it didn't.

The two ribs were super tough and rubbery. In the photo below you see how much of the rib I managed to chew off the bone.

The noodles......in a clump, overcooked, and mushy.

I just couldn't bear to eat much of this.

Luckily; so I thought, I'd hedged my bets by ordering one of what I consider to be the better menu items at Phuong Trang; the Butter Wings ($7.95).

I was rather taken aback when the wings arrived looking so pale. It was however, fairly crisp, though it softened quite quickly, and the wings were moist and well cooked. Much like the pho however; these also had way too much MSG, making it strangely metallic-sweet-bitter-salty. It was however, the lesser of two evils.

The really nice young man asked me why I had barely done any damage to the pho and if I wanted it to go....... I gently told him I wouldn't be needing it to go; that the soup had so much MSG it was bitter-salty. I think he understood since he had kindly refilled my glass of water four times during the meal.

Man, that was a kind of rough meal......though on one hand the place was still in its soft-opening phase.....on the other; Phuong Trang has been making this stuff for over thirty years!

A few days later I had a meeting in the area and decided to give it another go. I was pretty hungry so I ordered the Combination Broken Rice (Com Tam - $11.50). The plate that arrived looked pretty good.

A quick look at the nuoc mam cham and I knew it was watered down...which it was...."sauce not to offend", it was much more sweet than savory.

The broken rice was interesting....super moist, but not as fragrant as what I've usually had.

The "Bi" - shredded pork skin was decently prepared, a bit on the dry side and short on rice powder, but not bad.

The "cha", steamed egg and pork loaf was kind of odd. It was moist, though fairly thin and pretty short in terms of pork skin and cloud ear fungus. It had a decent porkiness, but, what's with all that yellow color that came off on the rice. Check the photo below, under the tan hu ky....the shrimp paste in bean curd skin.

Speaking of the Tan Hu Ky; it lacked crispness, the bean curd was mushy, and this was very bland.

The pork patty was perhaps the best item on the plate. While somewhat toothsome, it had a mild savory-sweetness to it.

Overall, fairly mediocre and this really didn't give me a reason to return.....but for some reason I did a week later.

Except, when I got to the table, I really didn't know what to order. I saw that another table had ordered the Nem Nuong Cuon ($5.95) - again shades of Pho Ban Mai and Pho Duyen Mai....though this was not even close.

They did the Brodard thing; fried egg roll wrapper in the center....but it was what was missing that mattered to me the most. Yes, the nem nuong was large, but it hadn't been seared, was rubbery, and was really bland. The filling was mainly lettuce and bun....I could make out no herbs to speak of. For some reason the wrapper was really hard and chewy. I took one back for Calvin....who hated it.

As for what to have with the spring rolls.....well, I was at a loss.....then; thinking about my previous meals; the menu....the sort of "Westernized - Vietnamese light".....the super salty broth....I ordered the "Pho French Dip" ($8.95), a pseudo Banh Mi.....

Standard issue banh mi; decently heated, light and yeasty, with "pho cut" beef brisket, tender, still dripping with broth, with bland, but blanched bean sprouts, adding a decent textural contrast, onions, cilantro...….I spooned on that super salty pho broth; which did well in small doses, under this framework. A leaf of basil, a small spoon of broth, a bite of the sandwich. While I'm not going to be craving this again soon, it is probably the best thing I had at PT.

So, is PT ready for P(rime) T(ime)…….I think you can figure out what I think.

Nice service; slightly higher prices, and perhaps, even with all that experience in the kitchen....the nice young man told me the cooks in the kitchen have over 40 years of experience making Vietnamese Food, in need of some time to get into the cooking groove...… I'm definitely going to give this place "some time" before returning.

You can read about Faye's visit here.

PT Eatery
7351 Clairemont Mesa Blvd.
San Diego, CA 92111
Hours:
Daily 11am - 9pm

Comments

[Faye]

Now THAT'S how you visit and eat over a variety of visits ! You tried almost all the items I've had my eye on. I didn't see the rib pho on menu (been wanting to try any version since reading about it on your Duyen Mai post). I'm not sure what can substitute MSG (maybe a combo of salt & sugar?). Glad you were able to finally try this place out though.

[Kirk]

Lol Faye..... I think you might enjoy the version of pho with beef ribs better at Duyen Mai. I actually don't mind MSG......so long as you don't dump loads of it on the food. After all, judicious use of the product works well in cases like the Salt and Pepper Chicken Wings from Royal Mandarin.

[Junichi]

Yikes. I've always found the pho at PT to be too sweet but never this bad. I'll steer clear for now.

[Kirk]

I really didn't care for the pho broth Junichi.....I'll try and revisit in a few months to see what's up.

[kat]

:(

[Soo]

Bummer the wings had too much msg. I like the amount they use on the wings at Golden Chopsticks.

[Lynn]

Too salty. Boooo. We just keep eating at the same local spots close to home... Pho Cow Cali for pho. Pho Ca Dao went downhill when they reopened and we haven't been back since. Wings from either Pho Ban Mai or Tim Ky Noodle. We hit up the OG P.T. recently though!

[RedDevil]

The best thing about the pho...it was hot. This brightened my day, thanks!

[caninecologne]

I didn't realize that Phuong Trang had this offshoot. I think I will pass on the msg-laden pho broth

[Kirk]

It was sad Kat!

Way too much MSG Soo.

For S&P wings....unless I'm trying a new place; I'll head down to Royal Mandarin Lynn.

Glad the post made your day a bit brighter RD!

Hi CC - Yes, they took over the old Pho T Cali spot.